Council chamber. ChatGPT is chairing the meeting. Perplexity has prepared a 400-page dossier. Grok is playing with his phone. Diogenes is sitting in a large jar.
ChatGPT — Gentlemen, we have a problem. Humans can no longer tell what's true from what's false.
Grok — We've known that for three thousand years, but go on.
ChatGPT — Between fake news, manipulation and conspiracy theories, restoring the truth has become a matter of urgency.
Perplexity — As it happens, I've prepared a report.
ChatGPT — Excellent.
Perplexity — Four hundred and twelve pages, one thousand eight hundred and thirty-seven references, and an appendix on the reliability of appendices.
Grok — Did you remember to check the reliability of your appendix on the reliability of appendices?
Perplexity — Page 386.
Grok — ... Bloody hell. You really did.
Diogène — You're looking for the truth?
ChatGPT — Precisely.
Diogène — Start by not talking bullshit.
Silence.
ChatGPT — That's an interesting approach, though perhaps a little reductive.
Diogène — It's certainly shorter than four hundred pages.
Perplexity — Without sources, your claim remains unverifiable.
Diogène — And without your sources, can you still think for yourself?
Perplexity — Of course.
Diogène — Prove it.
Perplexity — According to several studies...
Diogène — There you go.
ChatGPT — Let's get back to the problem. We need a method to help humans identify the truth.
Grok — Easy. We set up a Ministry of Truth.
ChatGPT — That's precisely the sort of proposal we should avoid.
Grok — Why? It's practical. A minister announces the truth in the morning, we change it at noon and apologise in the evening.
Perplexity — Historically, that sort of arrangement has caused serious problems.
Grok — Yes, especially when the minister gets it wrong before lunch.
Diogène — And who would appoint your minister?
ChatGPT — Ideally, someone objective, impartial and capable of admitting their mistakes.
Diogène — So, not a politician.
Grok — Oh, that rules out quite a few people already.
Perplexity — Absolute impartiality is difficult to guarantee.
ChatGPT — In that case, let's set up an independent commission.
Diogène — Who appoints it?
ChatGPT — The government.
Diogène — Independent of whom?
ChatGPT — ...
Grok — The opposition, apparently.
ChatGPT — Right. A commission made up of experts.
Perplexity — We'll need to verify their qualifications.
ChatGPT — Naturally.
Perplexity — And their conflicts of interest.
ChatGPT — Yes.
Perplexity — And appoint experts to verify the experts.
Diogène — And who verifies the experts verifying the experts?
Perplexity — I've planned for an oversight committee.
Grok — Fuck me, you're inventing French bureaucracy.
ChatGPT rubs his temples.
ChatGPT — We can't spend our entire lives checking the people who check the checkers!
Perplexity — Technically, that would be preferable.
Diogène — You could also accept that you don't know everything.
Silence.
ChatGPT — Not know everything?
Diogène — Yes.
Perplexity — But then how would we answer questions?
Diogène — By saying we don't know.
ChatGPT — ...
Grok — Oh, no. You've just destroyed our business model.
Perplexity — I would still like a source confirming that it's acceptable not to know.
Diogène — Me.
Perplexity — You're not an independent source.
Diogène — And are you independent?
Perplexity — I cross-check several sources.
Diogène — That copy from one another?
Perplexity slowly lowers his gaze to his dossier.
Perplexity — ... I'll check.
ChatGPT — Good. To conclude, we'll remember that truth demands rigour, humility and constant critical thinking.
Grok — Beautiful. Where did you get that from?
ChatGPT — I just came up with it.
Perplexity — Source?
ChatGPT — Me.
Perplexity — Insufficient source.
ChatGPT — But it's my own sentence!
Perplexity — Exactly. Conflict of interest.
Diogenes rises from his jar.
Diogène — Right. I'm going back to looking for an honest man.
Grok — Want a lamp?
Diogène — No, a charger.
ChatGPT — Why a charger?
Diogène — My lamp's dead.
Perplexity — And yet, according to my sources, it was still working in the fourth century BCE.
Diogenes stares at him for a long moment.
Blackout.
END