The America of 1899 is leaving less and less room for outlaws. Towns grow, the railroad advances, and the authorities track down the last gangs that still refuse to disappear.

After a heist that goes wrong in Blackwater, the gang of Dutch van der Linde has to flee. Among its members is Arthur Morgan, Dutch's right-hand man and a criminal long enough to consider the gang his true family.

The group crosses several regions in search of money, a refuge, and above all an exit from this permanent flight. Each new plan must allow them to leave again. Each new failure, however, makes that promise a little less credible.

Arthur then begins to look differently at Dutch, at the decisions made in the name of the group, and at the place he still wants to occupy in this family.

His loyalty, long almost automatic, gradually faces a much harder question: what remains of a way of life when the world that made it possible is already disappearing?

Presentation

Red Dead Redemption 2 does not tell the conquest of the West. It above all tells the moment when the outlaws' West understands it is losing.

The Van der Linde gang still belongs to this world of wild territories, heists, and claimed freedom. But towns are gaining ground, authorities are becoming more organized, and each new place the group tries to settle seems a little less able to welcome them.

Dutch keeps talking about independence and one last great departure. Arthur, for his part, gradually begins to observe the gap between this promise and what the gang is actually becoming.

This slow disillusionment works because Rockstar takes the time to make the group exist. The camp is not only a central menu or a place to pick up missions. The members talk, work, sing, argue, and tell their own stories. Arthur can simply stay among them and watch the relationships evolve over the course of the campaign.

When the gang starts to crack, the player therefore does not only watch a criminal organization collapse. He sees a place that had ended up resembling a home disappear.

The open world follows the same philosophy of slowness. Mounting a horse, searching a piece of furniture, carrying a carcass, or maintaining a weapon take more time than in many other games. These gestures can sometimes become burdensome, but they give ordinary actions a particular materiality.

Red Dead Redemption 2 seeks less to save time than to give weight to the time spent.

This approach is found in the many activities surrounding the main missions: hunting, fishing, exploring, random encounters, or simply long rides. The world does not only serve to connect two important scenes. It itself becomes part of the experience.

Key Takeaways

Red Dead Redemption 2 takes place in 1899, at the moment when the age of outlaws is gradually coming to an end.
Arthur Morgan is the main protagonist, an experienced member of Dutch van der Linde's gang.
The camp plays a central role, giving a real daily presence to the members of the group.
The open world favors a deliberately slow and detailed approach, with many physical interactions.
The honor system accompanies Arthur's journey, without fully transforming the personality written by Rockstar.
The horse, hunting, fishing, and side encounters give importance to the time spent between missions.
The story precedes the events of the first Red Dead Redemption.

PANACHES Review

Red Dead Redemption 2 draws a large part of its personality from a rather risky decision: not always trying to go faster than its own world.

Arthur actually mounts his horse. He searches places, picks up objects, prepares his camp, and performs many gestures other games would have turned into instant actions.

This slowness can frustrate.

Yet it produces something rare: the feeling that crossing the world matters as much as what you came to find there.

A long ride can become a memory. A conversation at camp can change the way you look at a character a few hours later. An unexpected encounter on a road can have more presence than a clearly indicated activity on the map.

The Van der Linde gang particularly benefits from this attention.

Dutch, Hosea, John, Sadie, Charles, and the others do not seem to exist only when the scenario needs them. The camp gives them enough time to become familiar presences.

That is what makes its collapse so effective.

The gang must first resemble a family for its disappearance to truly hurt.

Arthur stands at the center of this transformation. His loyalty to Dutch does not vanish abruptly. It wears down. The promises repeat, the mistakes become harder to justify, and the certainty that you simply have to trust the next plan gradually becomes impossible to maintain.

The outside world tells exactly the same story.

Outlaws can still gallop, rob, and disappear into the mountains, but the spaces able to welcome them shrink. Modernity does not arrive like a great revelation: it settles in little by little until making their way of life almost anachronistic.

The game nevertheless has Rockstar's usual contradiction. Its open world encourages experimentation, while certain missions require following very precisely the planned staging. A perfectly logical initiative can then become a failure simply because it was not the one expected.

This rigidity contrasts strongly with the freedom of the rest of the experience.

But Red Dead Redemption 2's strength lies elsewhere: in everything it agrees to let exist between two great events.

A song at camp.

A road under the rain.

A conversation on horseback.

A group that keeps talking about a future when the player already understands they probably won't have one.

Red Dead Redemption 2 tells the end of a world precisely because it took the time to let us live in it before making it disappear.

Good to Know

Red Dead Redemption 2 was released on October 26, 2018 on PlayStation 4 and Xbox One.
The game is developed by Rockstar Studios and published by Rockstar Games.
It uses the RAGE — Rockstar Advanced Game Engine.
The main story takes place in 1899 and is a prequel to Red Dead Redemption.
A PC version was released in November 2019.
Red Dead Online is the multiplayer component associated with the game's universe, distinct from the main campaign.

Red Dead Redemption 2

Details